Read the case and respond to the prompt that follows.
After Rob and Janet Colton finished veterinary school, they spent several years working for other veterinary clinics. Soon they felt it was time for them to start their own practice. They considered several towns in the south-central United States, visiting local chambers of commerce and studying each town’s demographics. They finally settled in Wardston, a small city in Arkansas. Wardston is a regional center for the surrounding counties, located at the intersection of a two major cross-state highways. The industry rule of thumb is that it takes a population of 1,500 pet owners to support one veterinarian. Wardston appeared to be an underserved area, and no other veterinarian in the area was treating large animals. A big factor in their decision also was the fact that Janet’s parents and three brothers lived in Wardston. “If we failed, at least we knew we could get a good homemade meal,” said Rob.
They bought an abandoned veterinary clinic with a three-quarter-acre plot of land on the major thoroughfare. The clinic, a sturdy 2,000-square-foot cinderblock structure, had been constructed in 1950 and needed major renovations. Rob and Janet were still paying off $145,000 in student loans and had no savings to draw on. However, Janet’s parents agreed to deed them a house and tract of land to get started. Now a property owner, Rob was able to borrow $265,000 from a local bank to renovate the clinic. When the clinic opened, the small concrete building had been transformed into the Wardston Animal Hospital, a 4,000-square-foot veterinary clinic, complete with treatment room, surgery, kennels, and offices.
As they had anticipated, the area badly needed another vet clinic, and business began to boom. They were able to pay off the loan from the local bank and make improvements to the clinic’s parking area. In 3 year, the Wardston Animal Hospital had grown large enough to need another vet, and Dr. Wayne Harper joined the practice. He soon became an equal partner with Rob and Janet.
The clinic building, while adequate for a small practice, was still 70-years-old with an inconvenient traffic flow. The building was designed around a single center hallway going from north to south. Clients going to exam rooms, animals being weighed, vets heading to treatment rooms, staff going to the break room all had to go down same central hallway. The partners always knew that they eventually wanted to build a new “ideal” clinic. Janet kept a notebook full of ideas and possible floor plans that they dubbed their “five-year plan.”
Five years later, a line of severe thunderstorms passed through the city. It was a Wednesday afternoon, the clinic’s early closure day, and the staff—with the exception of the office manager—had left the building. At 3:00 p.m., a tornado plowed through the northern part of the city, tearing the roof off the Wardston clinic and wrapping it around several nearby pine trees. For three hours, a steady downpour flooded the damaged building, leaving six inches of water on the treatment room floor. Worse still, the rainwater soaked into the insulation in the walls, the sheetrock on the walls, and the ceiling tiles. Volunteers, staff, even other veterinarians flocked to the clinic to help ferry the boarded animals to temporary homes and clean up the shredded interior. None of the animals were hurt, and no one was injured, although the clinic office manager was in shock for a few days.
Within two weeks, the partners were back in business, operating out of a rented doublewide office trailer set up on the north side of the parking lot. An inexpensive roof was quickly installed and a cleanup service was hired to start the long process of recovery. The cleaning crew soon realized the extent of the damage and told the partners that the cleanup would be very costly. They also warned that the soggy walls and ceiling would probably have mildew problems in the future no matter how thoroughly the building was cleaned.
Rob, Janet, and Wayne had to make a decision about how to proceed. As Rob saw it, there were three options to consider:
Plan A: Restore the building to its existing condition before the tornado. The $250,000 insurance settlement would just cover the renovation costs.
Plan B: Gut the old building and create a “new” building within the old shell, total cost approximately $750,000 and take 9-10 months to complete.
Plan C: Build the clinic of their dreams on land the partners owned adjacent to the clinic. The clinic would take a year to complete at a cost of $1,000,000.
Beyond the insurance settlement of $250,000 (less the costs paid to the roof replacement & the initial cleanup service), the partners had very little cash in which to pay for any work.
Which plan would you choose, and how would you finance the project? Explain your reasoning.
