1) Change in momentum, Δp
Δp = p2 - p1 = mV2 - mV1 = m(V2 - V1) = 0.5 kg * (1.3 m/s - 0) = 0.65 N*s
2) Impulse = F*Δt
F = m*a
Vf^2 = Vo^2 + 2aΔx = > a = [Vf^2 - Vo^2]/ (2Δx)
a = [(1.3 m/s)^2 - 0] / [2(1.5m - 0.5m)] = (1.3m/s)^2 / 2m = 0.845 m/s^2
F = m*a = 0.5kg * 0.845 m/s^2 = 0.4225 N
I = F*Δt = 0.4225N * (2.5 s -1s) = 0.63375 N*s
Conclusion:
Δp = 0.65 N*s
I = 0.63 N*s
Which are reasonably equal.
You have to take into account the experimental errors, which for the velocity is + / - 0.3 m/s.
That error is what makes the difference between the impulse and the change in momentum.
You can find the range of error by using the maximum and the minimum velocities of the range, i.e. 1.6 m/s and 1.0 m/s, and then you will find that the the Impulse and the Change of momentum are the same, inside the range of error provided by of the measurements.