Answer: Declined the proposed offer and raised counteroffer
Explanation:
Counter offer is the proposal of another offer in response to already raised offer.It is also termed as the offer that is raised as a measure for saving cost.It can terminate the original offer.
According to the mentioned scenario in question, Paul is rejecting the offer made by phone company by making a counteroffer.He is making the counter offer to eliminate the cartridge and paper case along with laser printer.Thus, he is decline the offer as cost-saving measure.