The arithmetic average of a group of numbers is their sum divided by the number of them.
arithmetic average = (-18.5 +28.5 +18 -9.6 +34.3 +26.5)%/6 = 13.20%
(Please note that it is meaningless to compute an arithmetic average of percentages that have different base values, as these do. It may be a decent exercise in arithmetic, but the result has no real-world meaning whatever.)
_____
The geometric mean of a set of n numbers is the n-th root of their product. Because these are stock returns, we aren't really interested in the geometric mean of the given percentages. (Such a mean of a set including negative numbers has no meaning in any event.) What we want to find is the geometric mean of the year-to-year multiplier of stock values. Then we want to convert that back to a rate of return.
... ((1-.185)(1+.285)(1+.18)(1-.096)(1+.343)(1+.265))^(1/6) ≈ 1.89791917^(1/6) ≈ 1.112703
This multiplier value of 1.1127 corresponds to a
... geometric average return = 11.27%